HD ready 1080p or not

[Piccolo26]

Hi,

I am looking to upgrade to a wide screen tv and would like to understand better the practical distinction between the newer technology higher resolution screens (hd ready 1080p) and lower resolution screens. I have pretty much decided to go with Pioneer plasma despite the expense and there appear to be two main contenders: PDP-LX5090 and PDP-428XD.

Since I am not a gamer and only somewhat interested in movies, it seems to me that the full 1080p might be wasted on me. Am I correct in assuming that 1920x1080 resolution will really only make a difference in gaming and Blu-ray for the forseeable future? Stated differently, is there any thought that conventional TV will move to that higher resolution any time within the next five years?

Given the substantial cost difference between the two TVs listed, it probably doesn't make much sense to buy the more expensive set if the additional level of technology will not actually affect the vast majority of what we view. Or am I missing something?

Finally, does anybody think I am wrong for focusing on Pioneer?

Thanks In Advance,

Piccolo

[Jimdefruit]

It will be some time, if at all,before tv transmissions increase their definition because the greater bandwidth needed is just not economically viable.

The need for greater definition is dictated by screen size/viewing distance from the screen.

For a normal home environment, resolution greater than 720p will not be noticed unless you are very close to the screen.

By all means go for the best screen you can afford. The Pioneer range is very good and there is a lot more to a screen than its resolution. The conversion electronics play a great part in producing a good picture. That is why two manufacturers, using the same actual plasma or ldc panel can have very different picture qualities.

The following chart shows the actual comparisons.

[Piccolo26]

Thanks for your comments. You have confirmed that my impressions were essentially sound.

Regards.

[lincsat]

I find most larger LCD's now support at least 1080i - I have a Tosh that is 1920x1080 and supports 1080p, wasn't that expensive either

With a larger screen the full 1920x1080 would be an advantage, but there's unlikely to be any 1080p transmissions for some time.